Multiple Deaths Linked to Breakup of United Methodist Church Over LGBTQ Policies

A simmering religious conflict in Nigeria has escalated into deadly violence, leaving three people dead, including two young children, and several homes in ruins. The tragic events have drawn global attention to the ongoing division within the Methodist Church over LGBTQ policies.

The violence erupted in Taraba State, northeastern Nigeria, on Sunday. According to reports from the United Methodist News Service (UMNS), a confrontation between opposing factions of the United Methodist Church (UMC) and the newly-formed Global Methodist Church (GMC) resulted in the shooting death of a UMC member.

Amid the chaos, the home of a United Methodist school overseer was set ablaze, claiming the lives of his two children, aged 2 and 4. Ten other church members sustained injuries during the clashes. The horrifying incident has left the community reeling and raised concerns about the growing tension in the region.

The violence stems from a deepening schism within the global Methodist community. Earlier this year, the UMC voted to repeal longstanding bans on LGBTQ ordination and same-sex marriage during its General Conference in May. While the decision marked a progressive shift, it also granted regional conferences the autonomy to set their own policies. This nuanced approach has not satisfied all parties.

In West Africa, the UMC’s Central Conference chose to uphold conservative policies, restricting marriage to heterosexual couples and aligning with national laws on LGBTQ issues. Meanwhile, conservative churches globally have split to form the GMC, which adheres to traditionalist views. The inaugural General Conference of the GMC was held earlier this year, solidifying its identity as a separate denomination.

Local bishops have strongly condemned the violence. In a joint statement, United Methodist bishops described the incident as a “shameful atrocity” among Christians who once shared the same spiritual family.

“We are outraged that such an atrocity would occur among Christians, especially brothers and sisters who were once part of the same Methodist family,” they said. “We urge all parties to cease hostilities and avoid spreading misinformation that could exacerbate tensions.”

The GMC’s Assembly of Bishops also released a statement expressing sorrow over the tragic loss of life. “We mourn the loss of human life, decry the use of violence in any form, and call on both Global Methodists and United Methodists to serve as agents of peace,” they stated. The GMC leadership has promised to investigate the allegations and ascertain the facts surrounding the incident.

This violent episode highlights the high stakes involved in religious divisions, particularly in regions where faith plays a central role in community identity. Nigeria, Africa’s most populous nation, is no stranger to religious and ethnic tensions. However, this incident underscores how theological disputes can spill into broader societal conflict.

Rev. James Olumide, a UMC minister based in Lagos, emphasized the need for reconciliation. “This is not just about theology; it’s about people’s lives and homes,” he said. “We must find a way to coexist despite our differences.”

As investigations continue, both denominations are urging their members to prioritize peace and dialogue. The tragedy serves as a stark reminder of the human cost of unresolved divisions. Leaders from both sides have reiterated their commitment to fostering understanding and healing within the fractured Methodist community.

For now, the focus remains on addressing the immediate aftermath—providing aid to affected families, rebuilding destroyed homes, and ensuring justice for the victims.