SOURCE: SCOTTS BLUFF COUNTY DETENTION CENTER

A Nebraska man who set his 74-year-old father on fire while the victim was speaking to his wife on the phone has been sentenced to 80 years to life in prison, bringing a disturbing family murder case to a close.

Elijah Cervantes, 45, received the lengthy sentence Friday, November 13, for killing his father, Anthony Cervantes, during a violent confrontation at the family’s Scottsbluff home in March 2025.

What makes the case particularly heartbreaking is that Anthony’s wife, Margaret, was on the other end of the phone when the attack unfolded.

According to investigators, Margaret heard her son mention a lighter before the conversation was interrupted by sounds of a struggle and an unusual noise. Alarmed by what she heard, she contacted authorities.

When police and firefighters arrived at the home on March 20, 2025, they discovered a fire and found Anthony dead outside the residence. Investigators determined that his son had poured gasoline on him and set him on fire.

But the violence did not end with the attack. Cervantes fled the property in an SUV, leading police on a pursuit after making a startling admission.

“I just burned up my dad. I’m not going back to prison. Come and catch me,” Cervantes allegedly told officers.

He was eventually apprehended that evening.

The killing was not Cervantes’ first violent offense. Court records showed he had previously been convicted of arson in 2016 and was sentenced to prison in 2018 after stabbing a family member with a letter opener. His criminal history also included more recent assault and drug-related convictions.

During Friday’s sentencing hearing, Cervantes acknowledged responsibility for his father’s death while describing his struggles with mental illness and substance abuse.

“I wish I could’ve used this time to say how much I loved my father,” he told the court. “Due to my condition, I’m responsible for his death. His blood is on my hands.”

His attorney, David Tarrell, argued that Cervantes had stopped taking prescribed medication and that his untreated mental health problems contributed to his violent behavior. Cervantes also admitted turning to illegal drugs to self-medicate.

The defense urged the judge to consider those circumstances when determining his punishment.

However, Scotts Bluff County Attorney Dave Eubanks pointed to Cervantes’ violent criminal history and the seriousness of his father’s murder. Prosecutors recommended a 50-year prison sentence.

District Judge Leo Dobrovolny ultimately imposed an even harsher punishment, sentencing Cervantes to 80 years to life after concluding that he remained a danger to society.

Cervantes had previously undergone court-ordered treatment to restore his competency to stand trial. In September, he was declared competent and pleaded no contest to second-degree murder. Additional charges, including first-degree arson, were dismissed as part of the plea agreement.

For the family, the sentence closes a criminal case that began with a devastating phone call and ended with a father’s death at the hands of his own son.

Anthony, remembered in his obituary as a hardworking and devoted family man, had also served as an in-home caregiver for his wife and others.

Leave a Reply