A veteran New York death investigator says one detail from a brutal Manhattan massacre still won’t leave her mind — and it’s not what you’d expect.
Barbara Butcher, who spent decades working with the city’s Medical Examiner’s Office, says the moment she stepped into the apartment above the iconic Carnegie Deli in 2001, she was hit with a wave of smells she’ll never forget.
“It was marijuana, blood, and red wine all at once,” she recalled. “That’s what stuck with me.”
What she walked into that day would become one of New York City’s most disturbing crime scenes — a cold-blooded execution that left three people dead, including actress Jennifer Stahl, best known for her role in Dirty Dancing.
On May 10, 2001, five friends were hanging out inside Stahl’s apartment in Manhattan’s theater district — drinking wine, relaxing, and, according to investigators, surrounded by jars of high-end marijuana she was allegedly selling.
Then came a knock at the door.
Moments later, two armed men were inside.
What followed was pure horror.
Three victims — Charles Helliwell III, Stephen King, and Stahl — were shot dead. Two others were shot in the head but somehow survived.
Investigators say the victims were bound with duct tape and executed one by one.
As Butcher worked the scene, she began reconstructing what she calls the “choreography of murder” — analyzing blood spatter, body positions, and gunshot wounds to piece together the final moments.
One detail would later blow apart a suspect’s defense.
Suspect Sean Salley claimed Jennifer Stahl’s death was an accident — that his hand was shaking when the gun went off.
But the forensics told a different story.
According to Butcher, the evidence showed the gun was held firmly against Stahl’s forehead before the trigger was pulled.
No hesitation. No accident.
“The forensics don’t lie,” she said.
Investigators quickly realized this wasn’t random.
There were no signs of forced entry. The killers appeared to know exactly where cash and drugs were kept. The place had been ransacked.
It looked like a robbery — but one that spiraled into something far darker.
Surveillance footage later captured the suspects casually entering the building… and then fleeing minutes later.
Both Salley and accomplice Andre Smith were eventually arrested and convicted, each sentenced to 25 years to life.
Nearly 25 years later, Butcher says the case still lingers.
Not just because of the violence — but because of how unnecessary it all was.
“They could have taken everything and walked away,” she said. “Why kill them?”
Even after investigating more than 5,000 death scenes, including the aftermath of September 11 attacks, she admits some cases never leave you.
And this one?
It comes back in flashes — the sounds, the sights… and especially the smell.
A mix of blood, weed, and wine — forever tied to one of New York’s most chilling murder scenes.
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.